Same feelings from me. I noticed that in the Boise State game when Tyler went to the sidelines that the other players met with him with big smiles and gave him a hug or at least a pat on the back. When Halliday hit the sidelines he ended up by himself. Cannot speak as to the maturity issue but it seems that the other players gravitate to Hilinski a lot more than Halliday's teammates did to him. Those who see some Halliday in Hilinski are in my opinion only considering the arms and the "gunslinger" mentality. Fair enough but after that I see nothing similar at all. As you have hinted, the "between the ears" aspect of the game is important too.