Smith is good on his recruiting of big men. He doesn't seem to understand the importance of having excellent point guard play. If you don't have that, then nothing else matters. And please don't mention not having Rice. He should've had a good backup.
If Smith wasn't good, didn't understand the importance of Point Guards, then he would not have Gotten, Bonton, Roberts, Flowers, Rice, Powell, Darling.
Bonton, Roberts, Flowers, were COMBO POINT GUARDS that were good at both SCORING, PASSING, ASSIST, POINT GUARD.
Rice was a PURE POINT GUARD, that got cancer, when he was supposed to be the starter instead.
Powell is a Point G/F/1/2/3, that got TWELVE ASSIST HIS FIRST WSU GAME, that has been BETWEEN how he was at Auburn, and Tennessee, at WSU.
Darling is a TRUE PURE POINT GUARD, that SCORED AND DISHED OUT ASSIST AT WILL IN HS(60 per game, and 5 to 7 to 9 ASSIST PER GAME)(SUPERIOR SHOOTING, DRIBBLING, PASSING, DRIVING, PENETRATION, SLASHING, BEATING OFF DRIBBLE(WHICH HE SHOWED OFF LAST GAME), ASSIST, ETC)(6-2, about 188 of MUSCLE)(PURE PG FRAME/TALENT/SKILL)
Now maybe Smith or one of his Assistants, hasn't been coaching as good as should be or left meat on bone,
But its certainly NOT because of not good enough POINT GUARD RECRUITING.
Also a lot of it is because of injuries.
And despite all the injuries the program has had under Smith, WSU still went to the NIT FINAL FOUR, WON 22,23,24 OVERALL TOTAL GAMES, AND WON 1,2 GAMES IN PAC 12 TOURNAMENT, WENT 11-9,(9-9, 8-10, is usually the best done(Even Sampson only had 9-9 at best), TIED FOR 5TH IN A CONFERENCE THAT WAS ONE OF THE TOUGHEST MBB CONFERENCES IN YEARS.
Now granted Smith left meat on the bone, as that team should have been a unbeaten in Noncon, 13-7, 3rd,4th place, 6,7,8 seed NCAA's, 2nd round elimination, 22,23,24,25,26 total win team, etc.
And they would have done that, if there had not been the lots of injuries, and if the Pac 12 had not been the best they had been in 10+ years.
I personally think it's a combo between injuries and slightly less good coaching.
As far as results Smith has slightly bettered Bone's Klay's, NIT FINAL FOUR, wins wise, as Smith won 22,23,24, compared to that season's 21,22 games.
Only Sampson, Raveling have had better on the court success, and Smith has done better then then, as it took Raveling, Sampson about 3 to 5 to 7 years to get the ball rolling(about 2.5 times as long as Smith.
I never thought I'd see the day at WSU that WSU have a Nebraska Tom Osbourne moments of having Tom Osbourne, Dickert, Smith, on Hot Seat, Fired, or calling for Hot Seat, Firing for ONLY winning 7 games(Dickert), 9, 10 games(Tom Osbourne, Nebraska), 22,23,24, games, NIT Final four(Smith).
Yes Doba, Bone got fired, but Doba was 5-7, 3,4,5 years after his big year, and Bone was only winning 10 games, 2,3,4 straight years after big year.
I think Smith will win 14,15,16 games, CBI, etc, and that this season is ANOMALLY, and Smith has injuries to blame, unlike Bone, Eastman, Doba, etc.
Has Smith left meat on Bone? Yes
Is it a lot of meat? No
And not that much meat difference between NIT FINAL FOUR, 23 WINS, 11-9, etc, and NCAA's, 1st round elimination.
Is there things to be frustrated about? Yes.
But a lot of that is injuries + a wee little tiny bit of slightly less good coaching.
And its certainly not a lack of recruiting good point guards.
A lot of Smith's point guards, have been very high rated, thought of, offers, etc.
Not Smith's fault that Rice came down with CANCER.
And the CANCER thing can have a big bad negative impact on the team, depending on how team, players handle it, no matter how good a job a coach does.