He's an excellent recruiter, but an average coach.
Yes, he's had a lot of injury issues (inexplicable/unlucky ones).
I really like Smith, but that is my assessment of him as a coach.
Turnovers are the ruin of a team's potential. They cannot be tolerated by a coach. Every single possession is valuable.
That's a fair assessment. I think Smith is a awesome recruiter, and between a average to above average coach.
I think he does care and does try to stop turnovers. I think he has a lot of semi Tony Bennet coaching skills.
He really values defense, rebounding, and only running and gunning, fast breaking, when makes sense, when under control.
And he believes in passing.
And unless he is doing coach speak, lying, he is constantly talking about how important it is to pass, take care of ball, limit turnovers, etc, and how he works on that in practice, games, etc.
But despite that, he gets players that either don't learn to take care of ball, limit turnovers, pass, etc.
Now some would say why doesn't he bench them?
Because they are too good in the other things that they do that are good, whether scoring, defense, etc.
Other might say then, then why does Smith recruit those players then?
Because they are 4,5 star recruits, that he Smith beat out Duke's, for that are athletic, that have potential, upside, that are too good in theory to pass on.
Could you imagine if Smith passed on high ranked, but semi turnover prone recruits that he would get a verbal, signed letter of intent, and instead went after the low ranked, non turnover prone Dick Bennet ESQUE, lower ranked recruits, and if Smith lost more because of that, and if it came out, that that's what he was doing, and if a 4 star recruit, said something like "I wanted to play at WSU, but Smith passed on me, said I was too turnover prone", the night of him being picked as a Lottery pick, etc.
Or can you Imagine if a player played at WSU and then if Smith were to try extremely hard to teach XYZ player to turnover ball less, and then if that XYZ player either wouldn't listen, or struggled to learn, and then if Smith were to bench him, and then if the player were to go-to another college, then XYZ player got picked as Lottery Pick and said "Man, I just wanted to play at WSU, but Smith benched me, permanently, because he said that I had too many turnovers, despite all the scoring, etc, I did"
I think some of it, is he thinks he can coach the players to turn ball over less.
But part of it is maybe not Smith's fault technically, because of Injuries.
Part of it is that when you have to replace almost all the key, rotational players, starters, almost whole team.
The players are new to each other. They haven't JELLED, haven't developed chemistry, haven't learned to play together.
Then you throw in injuries on top of that, and that's a recipe for more turnovers.
I'm sure next season, Smith will have less turnovers, unless has to Almost replace the whole team again, or gets a lot of injuries again.
Also I think that injuries, turnovers, lots of bad luck things happen to Smith.
But that said, I understand that the buck stops with the HC Smith.
But it's not like Smith is a bad coach, losing coach(yes he is 4-5 NOW, but by end of season, he will have at least 16,17 wins minimum.)
Smith has been 500+, winning, + has improved the team's results each year, + good conference record by WSU standards(8-10, 9-9, 10-8, etc, type), + CBI, + NIT FINAL FOUR, + 22,23 total wins in a season(reg season + PAC 12 tourny + NIT).
Smith is kind of like a Leach in bball, production wise
Does Smith, and did Leach leave meat on the bone?
Yes.
Is that frustrating?
Yes.
BUT Smith is not a Romar, Hopkins, etc, where a BAD coach, good recruiter.
Smith is a Awesome recruiter, and somewhere between a slightly barely below average to average to slightly above average X's and O's, teaching, coaching skills, etc.
I think Smith, WSU will win about 16,17 games this season, and NEXT SEASON, will probably win about 19,20,21,22,23 games, 2,3,4 in conference, 4,5,6 seed in NCAA, 2nd round, sweet 16, etc, IF Smith doesn't have to to REPLACE A LOT AGAIN, and IF Smith doesn't have a lot of injuries.
Can't believe a supposed Coug fan wanted Smith fired after the PVAM loss.
Bet he wanted Leach fired too.
That supposed Coug fan set the firing, hot seat bar at NCAA tourny or bust.