So not to stir the pot... and this isn't coming from a pro-Wulff position, but when measuring all of the other "worst coaches" in the history of college football...
How many other coaches were fired after showing the team actually getting better? (record wise and roster wise)
Aren't coaches getting fired when they look worse or with no improvement?
PW not only was a poor coach and leader, but he was a finger pointer. My disdain for him does not lie with his wins and loss record, it is with his unwillingness to accept responsibility, EVER, all the way to the end. At times, he would mention that coaches needed to do better, but his excuses for poor performance most often were external...training tables, bare-cupboards and the like. His attitude wasn't Coug-like during his coaching tenure. I think Cougars own-up to their mistakes and are able to address their weaknesses by seeking out folks that complement themselves. PW was the antithesis of this.
Can't believe I am chiming in on this never-ending train wreck of a thread.
That said, one (not me) could indeed argue that MoosyMoos pulled the trigger a year too soon. 5 years is kind of the standard for a "rebuild". $5 says if he could have put CML on ice for a year and come back to him CPW might have gotten that 5th year.
And as far as the finger-pointing goes, Sterk, who I happen to like more than many around here, has to share the blame too. I need to find the article where he trotted out the statistics on Doba's players D-1 offers (or lack of) as proof that the cupboard was bare. This is not to take away from CPW's blame.