Why do you guys keep harping on these big cities? Your whole premise is BS. First of all, you seem to assume that 100% of the voters in these big cities would vote one way? Conversely, NONE of the smaller states' votes would count?
Re: Senators - Senators represent a bunch of counties. Presidents represent a bunch of states. Aside from size, exactly what is the difference?
You all are just full of nonsense. Just beating our heads against the wall.
You don't get DEMOGRAPHICS.
BIG CITIES DO HAVE DIFFERENT VALUES, BELIEFS, MORALS, RELIGEONS, VOTES, ETC, THEN RURAL AREAS.
I have lived in both rural and BIG CITY areas, and the DEMOGRAPHICS of both, are DIAMETRICALLY OPPOSED, DIFFERENT, OPPOSITE, ETC.
BIG CITIES are about 89% Far left, liberal, socialist, Marxist, communist, are either apathetic towards or are atheist or are anti religion, are social justice warriors, are WOKEIST, Politically correct, pro abortion, apathetic towards or semi anti family values, are TAX AND SPEND LIKE CRAZY, etc.
BIG CITIES ARE HOME TO ANTIFA, TERRORIST, CRIMINALS, ACORN, CAIR, EXTREMIST, BLACK LIVES MATTER(FOUNDED BY CARD CARRYING COMMUNIST, A HATE, RACIST GROUP, A LOT LIKE ANTIFA), GANGS, CARTELLS, DRUGS, BLACK PANTHERS, etc.
Rural areas, altho they have very rare extremist, criminals, bigots, etc, about 89% are FARMERS, Christians, NOT PC, anti abortion, anti tax, anti spending, are OPPOSITE, DIFFERENT then BIG CITIES.
The Rural areas views, beliefs, RELIGEONS, morals, etc, that are the opposite of BIG CITIES DO NOT COUNT, DO NOT HAVE A VOICE, WILL NOT WIN AGAINST THE COMPLETELY OPPOSITE values, beliefs, etc, of the BIG CITIES, that are DIFFERENT then Rural ways.
Because of that A POPULAR VOTE System where the BIGGEST CITIES, SOLELY decide elections, over the rural areas, ways, is ANATHEMA to Rural areas.
WHY?
Because as soon as the BIG CITIES SOLELY determine who wins election, the BIG CITIES, start doing things, and start making, forcing, etc, Rural areas to do EVERYTHING the BIG CITY WAY, over the DIFFERENT RURAL WAY.
In a POPULAR VOTE THE BIG CITY WAY TRUMPS, ETC, THE RURAL AREA DIFFERENT WAY.
INSTEAD OF RURAL AREAS BEING ABLE TO DO THINGS THE WAY THEY WANT TO DO THINGS, BIG CITIES START BOSSING, TELLING THE RURAL AREAS WHAT TO DO.
AND BECAUSE OF THAT RURAL AREAS LOSE THE FREEDOM TO DO THINGS THEIR WAY.
Now you, others would say that the rural areas, Republicans, if they campaigned in Big Cities, or compromised, or learned moderation, etc, then the rural areas would win more, etc, in the Popular Vote system.
But Rural Areas, Republicans, have campaigned, have compromised at times, have moderated at times, and when they have done so, THE RURAL AREAS, REPUBLICANS, STILL DID NOT WIN, etc.
And that's because ITS THE BIG CITY WAY OR THE HIGHWAY in the POPULAR VOTE SYSTEM.
In the Electoral College, both the BIG CITY WAY, THAT IS DIFFERENT then the RURAL WAY BOTH GET FAIR, EQUAL voice, representation, where BOTH the BIG CITY WAY and the DIFFERENT RURAL AREA WAY, get fair, equal voice, representation, both get visited, campaigned, get their voice, votes, WAY, heard, and where both have about equal chance to have THEIR WAY.
ELECTIONS IS A BATTLE TO SEE WHICH WAY WILL BE FOLLOWED, DONE.
A POPULAR VOTE IS A BATTLE BETWEEN THE BIG CITY WAY AND THE RURAL FARMER WAY
A ELECTORAL COLLEGE VOTE IS A MORE FAIR BATTLE BETWEEN THE BIG CITY WAY AND THE RURAL FARMER WAY.