Tron, if I understand your long S corp example, you are having the S corp keep some retained earnings, which you are using to buy the CD's. In that case, the retained earnings are taxed and therefore you won't be buying as many CD's. S Corps pass everything through or it gets taxed as retained earnings. If I understood your example, it would not be my preferred choice.
I was going to point out that giant flaw in his logic (among others) but didn't have the energy. And the whole scenario was outlandish anyway.