FYI
CCC 1782 is written in the context of decisions perceived to be between good and evil, right or wrong, moral dilemmas, not personal preferences.
You are assuming this is a just a personal preference for Rolo. You have no evidence to suggest he is insincere.
Material cooperation with abortion is more than just a “personal preference.”
Rolo has never claimed or suggested that Covid or other vaccines, or the production thereof, is inherently evil or it is a sin to take them.
How do you know this? Were you present for the conversations he had with Chun or other WSU staff? Do you know what conversations he’s had with his family, friends, priest, etc?
There are reputable organizations, such as NCBC and the Charlotte Lozier Institute, that point to remote cooperation as a legitimate moral concern. Abortion is inherently evil (all orthodox Catholics accept this) and material cooperation can be sinful depending upon the proximity. Conscience is the guide when determining how close is too close.
He told June Jones that he didn't think he needed it and didn't like being told what to do! He also expressed some Bill Gates related health concerns to Dr. Palmer. That isn't a moral dilemma.
According to some reports. Do you really think someone would walk away from millions of dollars just because he “didn’t like being told what to do”? I know it would take more than that for me to do so. Why not Rolo? Are football coaches less greedy?
And given the large number that have claimed a religious exemption, he having a similar one isn’t fringe. There are those (such as myself) who make every effort to avoid abortion derived vaccines. I am more moderate than some, but I respect those who have decided to have zero cooperation.
I know a radiologist who was threatened with termination if he didn’t get the vaccine despite the fact he works from home. Only after threatening to sue did they back down. I also know a nurse who was denied an exemption even though she is in a clerical role and sees no patients and found a new job where they would grant it.
These employers doubted their sincerity and they were willing to fight for the right to keep their job and not violate their conscience. If Rolo was fired for being denied an exemption because they didn’t believe his sincerity, then I understand why he is fighting. However, if he is fighting it because there was no possible accommodation, then I think he is a greedy fool.
Going to war, or working with nuclear weapons while confronting the thou shall not kill commandment, that is type of situation CCC 1782 is addressing. Every Catholic who has taken 10 minutes of catechism knows that.
I assure you I had more than “10 minutes of catechism” and it covers much more than that.
And you are way off with respect to CCC 1782. The reference is to Dignitatis Humanae, which is primarily about religious freedom, not war or murder.
Declaration on religious freedom - Dignitatis humanae
www.vatican.va
As a counterpoint, consider these examples.
You are a prisoner of war and the guards require you to provide them sexual favors or be beaten severely. Your conscience says this is inappropriate and outside of the proper role of sex. Do you refuse?
Yiur government has banned the Catholic Church and you are required to attend the state church. Your conscience says the Catholic Church is the one true church. Do you refuse?
The government requires all pharmacists to fill hormone prescriptions for gender transitions . You are a pharmacist and conscience tells you this is contrary to natural law. Do you refuse such prescriptions?
You are a business owner and the law says you cannot serve certain races. Your conscience says that all races have equal dignity. Do you continue to serve those races barred under law?
You are a doctor at a correctional facility and the law requires convicted rapists to be medically castrated. Your conscience considers this mutilation and inhumane. Do you refuse to administer the drugs?
These are just a few I thought up. I’m sure there are thousands of more examples that are outside of “Going to war, or working with nuclear weapons while confronting the thou shall not kill commandment.”